Play Full-Game Yahtzee

Checked against Verhoeff’s Optimal Solitaire Yahtzee Player: 254.5896 for the whole game, to four decimals, and every option at eight of its positions within 0.01. How

Play a full 13-round game, and after every turn see how many points your choice left on the table against perfect play, the strategy that gets the most out of the whole scorecard rather than chasing one box. Perfect play averages 254.59 points a game.

Today’s deal

Everyone who plays today’s deal gets the same dice, so when you finish you can send a friend your score and they can try to beat it on the same game.

Turn 1 of 13
Scorecard
Points left on the board
Banked
0
Still to play for
254.6
Projected finish
254.6
Against par
+0

“Still to play for” is not a guess — it is what the solved table says this exact position is worth to a player who never misplays again, bonuses included. Add it to what you have banked and you get a projected finish, which starts every game at 254.59 and ends on your real score.

Upper bonus 63 more needed
0/63 so far, 105 still possible
Yahtzee bonus still live
Scoring 50 there arms the bonus
Given up so far 0
Ceiling still reachable: 375

What “optimal” means here

Most Yahtzee advice answers a smaller question than the one you actually face. Asking which dice to keep for a full house is a well-defined problem with a clean answer, and it is the question the keep-or-reroll guide answers. But you are never really playing for one category. You are playing a scorecard, and the value of a roll depends on which boxes are still open, how close the upper section is to its bonus, and whether the Yahtzee box has already paid out.

That is the question this page answers instead. Every decision you make is scored against the play that maximises your final total, taking the whole card into account — which sometimes means putting a perfectly good roll somewhere that looks wasteful, because the alternative costs more later.

536,448 positions, solved backwards

The solve works from the end of the game towards the start. With one box left there is nothing to weigh up — you score what you have — so that position’s value can be computed directly. With two boxes left, each choice leads to a one-box position whose value is now known, so the best choice is whichever leads to the better of those. Repeat that backwards through all thirteen rounds and every position has an exact value.

There are 536,448 positions that can actually be reached, and the whole table takes about twenty minutes to compute. None of it happens while you play: the table ships with this page, and the only thing worked out in your browser is the single position you are in right now.

From an empty scorecard, that table says perfect play averages 254.59 points. It is a useful number to hold onto while you play, because it is lower than most people guess. Part of the reason is that the headline category is rarer than its reputation: a Yahtzee lands 4.6% of the time even on a turn you spend both rerolls chasing it, so a strategy built around getting one is a strategy that usually fails.

Reading the critique

When the game ends, every turn is listed with its regret: how many points that decision gave up against the best available play, measured in expected final score rather than in the points you happened to score. A turn where you rolled badly costs you points but carries no regret — you cannot be blamed for dice. A turn where you had a choice and took the worse one shows up whether or not it happened to work out.

That distinction is the whole reason to play against a solver rather than against a target score. Total regret near zero means you played the card well, even in a game the dice ruined. It is also why a single run tells you less than you would like: the gap between a good player and perfect play is a few points a game, and the dice move you by dozens.

The daily deal

A free game rolls fresh dice. The daily deal fixes them instead: for each turn, each roll and each of the five positions on the table, the face that comes up is decided by the date. So everyone playing the same date’s deal opens every turn on the same roll, whatever they did on the turns before. The rerolls are fixed by position too. Hold the second and fifth dice and reroll the rest, and the three you roll show what those three positions show for everybody on that roll.

That makes two games on one deal comparable in a way two free games are not, but not perfectly: two players who hold different dice see different rerolls. That is why the score is the headline and points left on the table is the fair comparison. It measures each player against perfect play on the dice they actually saw. A second go at a deal you have already started is marked as a replay, because by then you have seen what is coming.

The rules this assumes

Standard thirteen-box scoring, the 35-point upper bonus at 63, 100 for every further Yahtzee once the Yahtzee box holds 50, and Tom Verhoeff’s joker rule: a Yahtzee rolled after the Yahtzee box is filled, with 50 or with a zero, pays full value in Full House and the straights once its own upper box is filled too. Those are the rules his Optimal Solitaire Yahtzee Player uses, which is what makes its published figures a check on this one.

Optimal play from an empty card averages 254.5896, the figure Verhoeff (1999) publishes for his Optimal Solitaire Yahtzee Player, to all four decimals, under the same rules. Position by position too: at eight positions taken from his player, from a first roll to a joker with the bonus banked, all 184 options it ranks are valued within 0.01 of his figures, and the best play agrees at every one.

The rules printed in the box go one step further and make you put such a Yahtzee in its upper box while that box is open. This table does not force that, so it can very occasionally recommend a box the printed rule would not allow. Full workings on the methodology page.

Try next

By Gabe · Updated · How every figure is checked

Cookies for analytics and ads; decline and both stop. Privacy