What should I keep? Your Yahtzee game, solved
Checked against Verhoeff’s Optimal Solitaire Yahtzee Player: 254.5896 for the whole game, to four decimals, and every option at eight of its positions within 0.01. How
Enter your scorecard and the dice in front of you. You get the best dice to keep and the best box to score, for your exact game, weighed against everything still open.
These dice are an example. Set them to yours, and fill in your scorecard below.
Keep the two 3s, reroll three
| Next best keeps | Costs you, on average |
|---|---|
| Keep the 2, the 3 and the 4, reroll two | 0.99 pts |
| Keep the two 3s and the 4, reroll two | 1.43 pts |
| Keep the 4, reroll four | 1.53 pts |
| If you scored this roll now | Scores | Costs you, on average |
|---|---|---|
| Threes | 6 | Best |
| Chance | 18 | 1.99 pts |
| Ones | 0 | 3.05 pts |
“Costs you” is how many points a play gives up, on average, against the best one, counting the rest of the game and not just this turn.
Upper section: 0, 63 short of the 63 that earns 35.
Only what changes the best play is asked for: the upper boxes need their scores, because the bonus depends on them, and the Yahtzee box needs to know 50 from a zero. What you scored in the other lower boxes changes your total, not your next move.
Why the answer changes with your scorecard
The same five dice can call for different keeps in different games. Early on, a pair of 3s is worth chasing for a big upper score, three of a kind and even a Yahtzee. Late in a game with Threes and the kinds already filled, the same pair may be worth nothing, and the right play is whatever your open boxes still pay for. A strategy chart cannot see your scorecard, which is why this asks for it.
Behind it is the whole game solved in advance: the best average score from every position a game can reach, worked backwards from the last box to the first. Your turn is then solved here, live, for the one position you are in: every way to keep and reroll, and every box you could score in, each valued as what it scores now plus what the position it leaves you in is worth. Played this way from the start, a game averages 254.59 points.
How to read “costs you”
Every figure is an average over the rest of the game, not a promise about this turn. The best play can still miss, and a worse one can still get lucky. What the numbers measure is how much a decision gives up on average, which is the only fair way to judge it before the dice land, and a small figure means the two plays are close, not that one of them is wrong.
The rules it plays
Standard Yahtzee: three rolls a turn, the 35-point bonus at 63 in the upper section, and 100 for every further Yahtzee once the Yahtzee box holds 50 (with a zero there, there is no bonus). Like any roll, a further Yahtzee can go in Three of a Kind, Four of a Kind or Chance for the total of the dice. What the joker rule adds is Full House and the straights at their full 25, 30 and 40, once the Yahtzee box is filled (50 or 0) and the upper box for that number is filled too. That is how Tom Verhoeff’s Optimal Solitaire Yahtzee Player, the standard computer solution of the game, reads the rules. The rules printed in the box go one step further and make you use the matching upper box while it is open; the answer above marks the boxes that rule would not allow, and says so if it changes the best play.
Check it yourself
Before it shipped, the advice here was compared, option by option, with the standard reference.
Optimal Solitaire Yahtzee Player — Tom Verhoeff and Erik Scheffers, TU Eindhoven
The same question answered by the player most often cited for it. At eight positions, from a first roll to a joker with the bonus banked, every option it lists was compared with the value here, keep by keep and box by box.
Optimal Solitaire Yahtzee Player: Rules — Tom Verhoeff
The joker and bonus rules the solve plays, as he states them.
Try next
By Gabe · Updated · How every figure is checked