Set mining: is the call right?

Checked against Deuces Cracked's and PokerStrategy's flop odds, exactly, and the hand-vs-hand engine as an identity. How

You hold a small pair, someone raises, and you call hoping to flop a set. A pocket pair flops a set or better 11.8% of the time, about one flop in 8.5, so the call is usually right only if you win enough on the times you hit. This works out how much, with every flop, turn and river counted exactly against the hand you think they hold.

With 55 against KK you flop a set or better 12.2% of the time, and take 81.5% of the pot from there to the river. On 8.5% of those flops they have flopped a higher set.

On these assumptions, they need to pay you 72.9 more, on average, each time you hit and they have not flopped a higher set — 38% of the 194 left behind. Averaged over every hit, the higher sets included (where the whole stack goes in and you are the one behind), that is 83.2 going in per hit. If they put in the whole stack every time, the call is worth +10.4 chips.

Even paid the whole stack every time, this call needs stacks of at least 9.8 times the call. The rule of thumb is 15 to 1, which leaves room for the times they pay you less.

Treating the set as a sure winner, you would need only 34.

How often they will pay is a read on the player, not a calculation, and this page does not pretend otherwise. It says how much the read has to be worth. The assumptions are listed below the tables.

The pot and the stacks

100 big blinds, an open to three called on the button:
Others who call too

Chips in any unit, dollars or big blinds. Expected chips, which is cash-game maths: in a tournament a stack you lose can cost more than one you win is worth, so what they must pay is higher there than this says.

55 against each hand

Their handThey must payYour shareThey hit too
81.178.1%higher set 8.5%
79.178.9%higher set 8.5%
77.379.6%higher set 8.5%
75.580.4%higher set 8.5%
73.881.1%higher set 8.5%
73.681.2%higher set 8.5%
73.381.3%higher set 8.5%
72.981.5%higher set 8.5%
74.680.7%higher set 8.5%
41.792.2%paired 24.4%
38.695.0%paired 24.4%
41.992.1%paired 24.4%
38.894.9%paired 24.4%
4292.0%paired 24.4%
38.994.8%paired 24.4%
41.892.1%paired 24.4%
38.794.9%paired 24.4%
53.7

“They must pay” is at the pot, call and stack above, on average each time you hit and they have not flopped a higher set. “Any of these” weights each hand by how many ways it can be dealt alongside your pair.

How deep the stacks need to be

The shortest stack, as a multiple of the call, at which calling breaks even if they put in everything every time you hit (and you lose the whole stack on a higher set). It is a floor: they will not always pay. Worked for an open to three big blinds called with both blinds in, so the pot before your call is one and a half times the call, with no rake and nobody else in.

Your pairAgainst a higher pairAgainst AKAgainst any of them
2210.1×6.5×8.1×
3310.1×6.5×8.0×
4410.2×6.5×8.0×
5510.2×6.6×7.9×
6610.1×6.4×7.7×
7710.1×6.4×7.6×
8810.2×6.4×7.6×
9910.2×6.4×7.6×
TT10.3×7.2×8.2×
JJ10.1×7.2×8.6×
QQ9.9×7.2×9.1×
KK9.7×15.0×8.9×

The common rule of thumb asks for 15 to 1: at least 15 times the call left in their stack. Every other figure here is below it, but KK against AK needs 15.0× even when paid in full. There the rule is the break-even line itself, with nothing to spare for the times they pay you less. KK against AK is the expensive one because it hits 6.3% of the time rather than 12.2%: AK holds one of its kings.

One flop in 8.5

With only your two cards known there are 19,600 possible flops. 2,112 give you a set (10.8%), 144 a full house because the other two cards pair (0.7%), and 48 four of a kind (0.2%). Together that is 11.8%, or 7.5 to 1 against. Some tables print the set alone as 11.5%: that counts the full houses too, since each one is a set with a pair on the board.

Knowing their hand moves it. If they hold a different pair, two of the unseen cards are known not to be yours, and you hit 12.2% of the time instead. Against AK, KK hits only 6.3%, because AK holds one of the two kings it needs.

A set is not a lock against a bigger pair

Against a higher pair, a flopped set takes between 78.0% and 81.9% of the pot from the flop to the river, about four parts in five rather than the near-certainty it feels like. The biggest reason: on 8.5% of the flops that give you a set, about one in 12, they have flopped a higher one, whatever the two pairs are. The rest is the turn and river: their two remaining cards of their rank, and straights and flushes that come runner-runner. Set over set is also the one hand where the whole stack reliably goes in, and you are the one behind. That is why the sum above takes the stack off you on those flops rather than averaging them in with the rest.

AK is the opposite problem

Against AK, a pair below a king takes between 89.0% and 96.0% of the pot once it flops a set, better than against any bigger pair. But AK has paired on only 24.4% of those flops. The rest of the time it holds ace-high, and whether ace-high pays you anything is exactly the read the sum leaves to you. Against a bigger pair you take less of the pot when you hit, but they always hold an overpair; against AK you take more of it, but on at least 75.6% of those flops they hold only ace-high. Which is better to mine against depends on what each will pay, and the counting cannot say. When AK has paired the king and you hold KK, that pair is yours to beat: the table marks it as one.

What this assumes

  • You fold every flop that misses. Playing on after a miss is a choice you could make, so it can only add to the call’s value; this leaves it out.
  • When you hit, the hand is played to the river, and your share is counted exactly over every turn and river. On a higher set the whole stack goes in; otherwise they pay whatever amount the page is solving for.
  • One hand, or a mix of the listed ones. “Any of these” is the higher pairs and AK, AQ, AJ and KQ, weighted by how often each is dealt. A real raiser also holds hands that are not here, such as suited connectors and smaller pairs, and none of them is counted.
  • Others who call are dead money. Their calls go into the pot you can win, and the page assumes they drop out once the flop comes. If they stay in with draws your share falls; if they pay you too, you win more. Neither is counted.
  • Position and the squeeze are not in it. Out of position it is usually harder to get paid for the same set, and a player behind you can raise before you see a flop at all.
  • Rake, if you give it, comes out of each pot you win: the percentage of the pot, up to the cap.

For a call that is not about sets, the pot odds calculator does the same sum for any draw.

Check it yourself

Counted here exactly, with the flop odds checked against two published tables and the stack rule against the article it comes from.

  1. Deuces Cracked, "Poker probability reference"

    Prints a set or better at 11.8% (to three places, 11.755%), a full house at 0.735% and quads at 0.245%, all reproduced here. Its "exactly a set" figure of 11.510% counts full houses as sets.

  2. PokerStrategy, "Texas Hold'em probabilities"

    Prints the same flop as 11.8%, 7.5 to 1 against.

  3. PokerNews, "Set Mining 101" (Nathan Williams, 2019)

    The 15-to-1 rule of thumb, stated as their stack against the call. The table above is the break-even line it sits on top of.

Try next

By Gabe · Updated · How every figure is checked

Cookies for analytics and ads; decline and both stop. Privacy