The most points you can win and still lose
Checked against OEIS A368009 and A368008, exactly (106 of 168 points in a best-of-three, 171 of 264 in a best-of-five), and a second solve by hand. How
Everyone who watches tennis has seen it: the player who won more points loses the match. It happens because points only count through games, and games only count through sets — each one resets to zero. That raises an exact question with nothing to estimate: how far can it go?
Best of three, tiebreak at 6-6 in every set
63.1%
of the points — 106 of 168 — and still lose, 6-7 6-0 6-7.
How the scoreline is built
Every game you win, you win to love. Every game you lose, you lose 2-4, and every tiebreak you lose goes 5-7. The set you are allowed to win, you win 6-0 without dropping a point — it banks 24 points at no cost. Then you lose the sets that decide the match as narrowly as the scoring allows. That is the whole trick: win decisively where it does not matter, lose by the smallest possible margin where it does.
Deuce makes it worse
The instinct is that dragging the games you lose to deuce banks you extra points. It does raise your share of that game: losing a game 2-4 gives you 33% of its points, and taking it through one deuce to 3-5 gives you 37.5%. But you are already above 63% overall, so every extra deuce point pours volume into a bucket scoring below your average and drags the total down. The ceiling takes every lost game in the minimum four points.
Tiebreaks work the same way. Losing one 5-7 is better than losing it 6-8, for the same reason.
The format moves the ceiling
- Best of five goes higher — 64.8%, 171 of 264. More sets means more places to bank a love set, so a longer match leaves more room to lose while winning.
- A match tiebreak raises it — 64.0%. Replacing a whole third set with one short tiebreak means the decider is a small part of the match, so losing it narrowly costs less of the total.
- No-ad scoring raises it most — 66.0%, 66 of 100, very nearly two points in every three. At 3-3 no-ad plays a single deciding point, so a game can be lost 3-4: three of the seven points, the best lost game any format allows. It is the same logic as deuce, run the other way — what you want in a game you lose is as many points as possible for as few points played.
Of the six formats this site models, that one has the highest ceiling.
What this does not tell you
This is a ceiling, not a rate. It says what the scoring system permits, not how often real matches come anywhere near it. How often the player with more points loses is a question about real players, answered by match records rather than by the rules: Tennis Abstract keeps a running table of tour matches won by the player who lost more of the points (linked below). Nothing on this page needs a probability at all: it is counting, which is why it is exact.
The ceiling is exact within each format as stated. Every game, tiebreak and set shape was searched; a different tiebreak length or set length would move it, which is exactly what the formats page is about.
Check it yourself
The ceilings are solved here exactly and then rebuilt by hand. Two have been published independently and agree exactly. A third, for a newer format, does not, and the arithmetic is set out below so you can check which is right.
A368009: highest points ratio in a lost three-set match — Marco Ripà, OEIS, December 2023
106 points won to 62 lost, from 6-0 6-7 6-7 with every lost game 2-4 and both tiebreaks lost 5-7: the same scoreline and the same count as the best-of-three tab above.
A368008: the same for five sets — Marco Ripà, OEIS, December 2023
171 won to 93 lost, matching the best-of-five tab exactly.
A368146: five sets with a 10-point final-set tiebreak — Marco Ripà, OEIS, December 2023
Where this site disagrees, and why. It gives 174 won to 96 lost, losing the decider 6-7 (8-10). Losing the decider 4-6 instead gives 158 won to 86 lost, a higher share (64.8% against 64.4%), because the extra two games and a 10-point tiebreak add 16 points won against 10 lost, a worse ratio than the match already has.
Can You Fail to Lose the Tennis Match? — The Fiddler on the Proof, 12 July 2024
The same question posed as a puzzle, for a three-set match with seven-point tiebreaks.
ATP lottery matches — Tennis Abstract
How often it actually happens: a running table of this season’s tour matches won by the player who lost more of the points.
Try next
By Gabe · Updated · How every figure is checked