Pair of 4s against a dealer 5
Checked against the textbook basic-strategy chart: 5,5 doubles, 8,8 splits, 9,9 stands against a 7, hard 12 hits against 2 and 3. How
This is one of the closest decisions in blackjack. Split is correct, but it beats hit by 0.95% of your bet — and of the 350 hand-versus-upcard spots on the chart, only 8 are closer.
Every option, ranked
| Action | Expected return | Cost vs. best |
|---|---|---|
| Splitcorrect | 8.03% | — |
| Hit | 7.08% | −0.95% |
| Double | 0.35% | −7.68% |
| Stand | -16.72% | −24.75% |
Expected return per unit staked, from an exact recursive engine rather than a copied chart. Figures are for Dealer Stands on Soft 17, DAS, pays 3:2. Actions not shown are not legal here.
It genuinely depends on the house rules
“It depends” is usually a dodge. Here it is literally true: under one of the six rule sets modelled, the correct play is something other than split. Where you cannot double after splitting, it becomes hit.
| S17 · 3:2, S17 · Surrender, S17 · No Peek, S17 · 6:5 | Split | 8.0% |
| H17 · 3:2 | Split | 8.3% |
| S17 · No DAS | Hit | 7.1% |
What splitting actually buys
Splitting turns one hand into two, each starting from a single 4 against the dealer’s 5, with a second bet on the table. Across both hands it is worth 8.03% of your original bet, against 7.08% for hit. Take away the right to double after splitting and the play becomes hit. That is the only rule modelled that changes it, which says how much of the split’s value is in the doubles a small card sets up.
How often it comes up, and what a mistake costs
In a six-deck game you are dealt this exact spot about once every 2,273 hands. Getting it wrong every single time adds 0.00092 percentage points to the house edge. Of the 31 close calls, that makes it the 10th cheapest to get wrong. The mistakes page puts that against the habits that actually cost players money.
What the count does to this
Split is correct at a neutral shoe, but not at every shoe. The two actions are worth exactly the same at a Hi-Lo true count of −0.80, so below that hit is the better play — a deviation conventionally written as an index of −1.
Where that number comes from, and what one card of each rank is actually worth, is on the card counting page.
The closest calls either side of this one
Try next
By Gabe · Updated · How every figure is checked