The 5 and 9 in Catan

Share of rolls, each
11.1%
On each token
4 pips

The 5 and the 9 are mirror images: 4 of the 36 ways two dice can land make 5, and exactly as many make 9, because every way to roll one turns into a way to roll the other when you flip both dice over (a 1 becomes a 6, a 2 a 5). Each comes up about every 9.0 rolls, 11.1 times in 100. That makes them the 2nd most productive of the 5 pairs.

Why the pips are the odds

The dots on a number token are not decoration and they are not a rating someone assigned. They are a count: 4 pips because there are exactly 4 ways for two dice to make each of them. Read the pips and you have read the probability.

Making 5
  • 1 + 4
  • 2 + 3
  • 3 + 2
  • 4 + 1
Making 9
  • 3 + 6
  • 4 + 5
  • 5 + 4
  • 6 + 3
21/36
32/36
43/36
54/36
65/36
76/36
85/36
94/36
103/36
112/36
121/36

Ways to roll each sum with two dice. 7 is the peak, which is why it moves the robber instead of producing anything.

What a settlement here is worth

A settlement on a single 5 or 9 hex earns 0.111 cards per roll — 11.1 over 100 rolls, and double that for a city. Against the weakest numbers on the board that is 4× the production, which is the entire reason placement matters more than almost any later decision.

A spot touching a 5 and a 9 is not doubling up: the two can never come up on the same roll, so it produces on 22.2% of rolls, one card at a time. Two hexes on the same number produce exactly as much in total, but two cards at once on half as many rolls (11.1%): one correlated event rather than two. The resource odds calculator handles that properly for a board you actually build.

Every number

Building a real board? Paint your settlements and get exact production per turn, or weigh a trade against it in the trade evaluator.

By Gabe · Updated · How every figure is checked

Cookies for analytics and ads; decline and both stop. Privacy